HIIT Workouts For Weight Loss? The Answer Isn’t Black & White

    As humans we always want information displayed as – Do This Not That. Eat This Not That. It’s easy. It’s clear and let’s face it nuances don’t sell. Over the last few decades we have been sold High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) hard.

    The research is fairly clear that HIIT overpowers steady state cardiovascular training in weight loss, fat loss, and in promoting healthy changes in blood sugar and insulin sensitivity. This all makes sense given the mechanisms of action, but it is not the end of the story or the only side.

    Those who despise steady state cardio now say – nope, never need it again. Deuces. (This tends to happen with a lot of things, but the best example is stretching. The people that don’t like to stretch but who need it the most don’t do it, and the people that love it tend to do too much).

    The problem isn’t HIIT, it is that we aren’t building or maintaining the foundation to really use HIIT well and recover from it. HIIT is powerful. Potent. But so is cardiac output work.

    I used to be a HIIT Jedi. Everything I ever did with myself and clients was in intervals. My justification was the research on fat loss. I was also an early disciple of Boyle and I bought into the ideology that we need only work inside the intervals of our sport or perhaps a little longer…but not too much!

    There is no debating that football players work in short bursts of activity. The average NFL play is 5-15 seconds. The most a baseball player is ever likely to run is 60 yards or about 6 to 7 seconds. Thus, the contemporary strength coach has had the mentality that speed and power athletes don’t need chronic cardio. Which is true they don’t, but they do need movement and cardiac output work.

    Yet, this Interval Philosophy has now been extrapolated to everyone ever. Why would I go for a hike or move throughout the day when I can just get this whole thing done in 4 minutes of negative rest intervals of Tabata. Party.

    The problem isn’t HIIT, it is that we aren’t building or maintaining the foundation to really use HIIT well and recover from it. HIIT is powerful. Potent. But so is cardiac output work. In fact if given the choice of whether to move throughout the day or have a structured exercise regimen, one should always chose movement. It trumps structured exercise in the research as far as longevity and health, and is much more in tune with how we have evolved into being.

    What Are the Benefits of HIIT?

    What are the Benefits of HIIT

    ● Concentric Hypertrophy of the Heart – Increased stroke volume
    ● EPOC – Increased After Burn
    ● Time Efficient
    ● Weight Loss
    ● Increased Insulin Sensitivity – Glycogen Depletion
    ● Opioid High – Feels Soooo Good
    ● Improved Buffering Capacity (Lactate)
    ● Improved Anaerobic Capacity & Power if programmed correctly.
    ● Increased Muscular Hypertrophy (Circuit Training)

    What Are the Negatives?

    ● Concentric Hypertrophy of the Heart – Limits blood volume. (If overdosed can cause excess acidosis leading to damage.)
    ● Promotes the idea that you can just sit or stand still the rest of the day – Lack of time spent in movement exploration (Stuck in 2D?)
    ● Sympathetic Driver – Over prescription can exhaust the endocrine system.
    ● CNS Fatigue – Taps emotional energy (lingering fatigue can affect motor learning and strength)
    ● Destroys Mitochondria – Heart and Muscle Fibers
    ● Randomness – very few know how to progress this type of work well
    ● Sacrifices in Movement Quality in Highly Fatigued States

    What Are the Benefits of Cardiac Output or Movement Work at Low Heart Rate Ranges (120-130bm) for 30-40 min?

    What Are the Benefits of Cardiac Output or Movement Work at Low Heart Rate Ranges (120-130bm) for 30-40 min?

    * this zone is generally a lot lower than the endurance hobbyists who creep up far too high and live in what is called the dead zone of training or Zone 3 and 4 for Ben Greenfield Disciples out there.

    ● Eccentric Hypertrophy of the Heart – Increases the stretch reflex of the heart. Less energy used per beat.
    ● Increased Capillarization
    ● Increased Mitochondrial Density
    ● Parasympathetic Driver
    ● Improved Oxygen Utilization Within The Muscles
    ● Increased Aerobic Capacity
    ● Increased Recovery Between Sets or Intervals
    ● Increases Recovery Between Workouts
    ● Reduces Resting Heart Rate
    ● Can Increase Time to Fatigue During Skill Acquisition – More focused training

    What Are the Negatives of Cardiac Output or Movement Work?

    HIIT Workouts For Weight Loss? The Answer Isn't Black & White

    ● Let’s Be Honest – Boredom – Few use their imaginations
    ● Can Eat Up at Muscle – if done in excess and without added resistance training
    ● Can Disrupt Endocrine Function – if done in excess and without added resistance training
    ● Can Negatively Affect Hypertrophy and Strength – if done incorrectly
    ● Increased Chances of Overuse Injuries, If Kept to a Single Modality

    Over the last few decades we have moved from the chronic cardio epidemic of the 80s and 90s to the current regime of HIIT and self destruction. We believe the pendulum is swinging back towards people gaining an understanding and using sound principles to decide the dose and variety of conditioning that fits them best.

    But, no matter what you choose, Cardiac Output Work is equally powerful and there aren’t a lot of negatives related to programming 3D movement in low heart rate zones. AKA accumulating steps and triplanar work throughout the day.

    Yes, running from a lion is important and leaves you with a flood of opiates in the brain, but equally so is foraging, playing, and dancing. This big industrialized engine of a world has made us far more efficient, but has it ever made us healthier?

    The answer to that question is looking more and more to be a resounding no. HIIT is not black and white and without movement, it is probably dangerous and unproductive in a long term view.

    Is it better than nothing? Depends on the Athlete.
    Is it better than moving throughout the day? No way.
    Is combining both in an educated manner the way to go? F@#$ Yes.


    Author:

    Ben House

    Ben House Ben House, PhD, CN, FDN, fNMT, NCSF, USAW LI SPC has worked as a Strength and Conditioning Coach and Nutritionist since 2006. House is currently the owner and founder of Functional Medicine Costa Rica. House was accepted to medical school without an undergraduate degree, but elected to finish his degree and pursue a career in the health and fitness sector. He is currently practicing Functional Medicine after finishing his PhD and a multi-year metabolic health study within the Nutritional Sciences Department at UT-Austin. House has numerous publications in peer reviewed scientific journals such as The International Journal of Obesity, has presented his work at multiple international conferences, and lectures regularly on health and nutrition at The University of Texas.


    Keep-It™ Money Back Guarantee
    We’ve taken the tricks out of the Money Back Guarantee. Most companies push out mediocre products and rely on the fact that dissatisfied customers are too busy to go through the hassle of returning the product to qualify for their money back. We’re confident you’ll love your Onnit supplements, and we’re not gonna play games with you.
    Order any of our entry size supplements, and if you don’t like it, you can keep it. Notify us and we’ll give you a full refund right there on the spot. No complicated intake forms and no return necessary. We trust you, but to protect against fraud, the Keep-It™ guarantee is valid only for first time purchases of a product, and redeemable up to three months after purchase.
    Multiple bottles, foods, apparel and gear are subject to our basic, no stress money back guarantee. Fitness equipment, personal care products, knowledge purchases, and DVDs are not eligible. For more information and a full list of products that qualify, visit our Keep-It™ page. To process a refund, visit our support page.
    Military Discount
    In thanks to our military service men and women, we're extending a 15% discount on all products purchased at Onnit.com.
    Anyone shipping their order to an APO/FPO/DPO address will have a 15% discount automatically applied to their order.
    In order to validate your account, please either send an email from your .mil email address or send in a snapshot of your military ID to our customer service help desk. Blacking out rank and or post is acceptable. In either case, please include the civilian email address or whichever email address you have registered with Onnit.com somewhere in the message body so we know which account to verify. Please setup an account with Onnit.com prior to submitting your request.
    * US Military members, please choose United States as your destination country when creating your customer profile, as this will ensure your package ships via USPS and that you are not given international shipping rates.
    Subscribe & Save 15% now
    With a subscription, you'll get your favorite Onnit products whenever you want, at 15% off. All automatic, worry free, and with our same great money back guarantee.
    Cancel, pause, or adjust your order at any time, hassle free. Your credit card will only be charged when your order ships. The discount applied every time is 15% off. Sometimes we run big sales, which means you'll get those same big discounts on your subscriptions, too. Since it would be weird to subscribe to a kettlebell, the subscriptions and subscription discounts are only for things you'll need often, like supplements, foods, and personal care items.

    Secure Shopping

    We implement a variety of security measures to maintain the safety of your personal information when you place an order or enter, submit, or access any information on our website. We incorporate physical, electronic, and administrative procedures to safeguard the confidentiality of your personal information, including Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) for the encryption of all financial transactions through the website. We use industry-standard, 256bit SSL encryption to protect your personal information online, and we also take several steps to protect your personal information in our facilities. For example, when you visit the website, you access servers that are kept in a secure physical environment, behind a locked cage and a hardware firewall. After a transaction, your credit card information is not stored on our servers.