Multivitamin Researchers: “Case Is Closed… Because I Said So?”

    Multivitamin Researchers: “Case Is Closed…Because I Said So?”

    Sensationalist Headlines about Efficacy of Supplements Spin a Misleading Tale.

    Multivitamins are all over the news with sensational headlines like Multivitamin Researchers Say Case Is Closed, Supplements Don’t Boost Health.”

    This was prompted from several studies that recently point to the inefficiency of preventing certain chronic disease with generic multivitamins.  However, the headlines and editorials badly misrepresent the actual scientific conclusions.

    Here is what has actually been shown in these trials:

    1. A study following male physicians over age 65 showed no improvement in cognitive decline using generic multivitamin supplementation.

    2.  A study shows high dose multivitamins had no effect on the progression of heart disease in heart attack survivors.

    3.  A previously released study concludes: “Limited evidence supports any benefit from vitamin and mineral supplementation for the prevention of cancer or cardiovascular disease. Two trials found a small, borderline-significant benefit from multivitamin supplements on cancer in men only and no effect on cardiovascular disease.”

    Armed with those studies, the Annals of Internal medicine released a strongly worded editorial claiming, “Enough Is Enough: Stop Wasting Money on Vitamin and Mineral Supplements.”

    Even taking the studies at face value, all that has actually been shown is that run of the mill, presumably synthetic multivitamins don’t prevent cognitive decline in men over 65, don’t prevent progression of heart disease in heart attack survivors, and have borderline significant benefit in preventing cancer.

    To make the broad claim that multivitamins and mineral supplements are a waste of money “case closed” based upon that data is at the very least an astounding leap.

    While the studies may have merit in showing that stemming the tide of these degenerative conditions with untargeted multivitamins alone is ineffective, there are several flaws in the conclusions:

    A. Multivitamins are not all created equal and simply because one type doesn’t work for something, it doesn’t necessarily follow that another multivitamin wouldn’t be effective.  For example I personally take a live source liquid multi B vitamin from a company called Premier Labs. I notice a dramatic difference in efficacy taking that vs a synthetic tableted B vitamin, even though the tableted vitamin has much higher quantities of each marker. B Vitamin intake for stress is one of the well documented benefits from supplementation (See 2, and 4 below via Pubmed).

    B. There are several studies with generic multivitamins for important quality of life health markers that have shown statistically significant benefit.

    1. Infectious Illness Prevention:   http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12614088

    2. Mood and Stress:  http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22095836

    3. Cognition:  http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22711385

    4. Work Stress:  http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21905094

    5. Juvenile Delinquency:  http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10706231

    The Easiest Way to Get Optimized

    Multivitamin Researchers: “Case Is Closed… Because I Said So?”

    All of this said, allow me to clarify Onnit’s position on multivitamins.  Namely that we have never been a champion of multivitamins, and as such there is nothing shocking about the results of these studies.

    We don’t sell a multivitamin, we have never recommended any customers to take one, and there are potentially very good reasons for that.  We certainly would never propose that generic multivitamins alone could prevent large degenerative conditions like heart disease progression or cognitive decline in the elderly.

    Dr. Dan Engle MD, director of medicine at the Rejuvenation and Performance Institute lays out some of the limitations of multivitamins:

    “There are varying studies on the absorption rates of vitamins and minerals, with many showing that the compressed pill form of vitamins have very poor absorption rates.  Add this poor absorption rate to the use of synthetic ingredients, toxic binders, and excipients in most of the tableted supplements and what results is essentially expensive urine.

    Let’s briefly take a closer look at absorption.  The avenues of absorption of oral supplementation are via the mucous membranes of the digestive system that start in the mouth and travel all the way to the colon.  Notably, digestion and absorption all start in the mouth.  This is why swishing vitamins and minerals (like a powdered form in water or a smoothie) in your mouth for 15-20 seconds before swallowing (and chewing all your food super well) can significantly increase the absorption rate.  As Ghandi said, “Chew your liquids and drink your solids,” in a process of thorough chewing also known as Fletcherization.  This improvement in absorption is further made easy and available through the use of powder and liquid base supplements (versus compressed tablets), because there is more surface area available for the nutrients to access and gain entry into the body from start to finish, and less reliance on the body to breakdown a pill. From there, absorption is throughout the GI system, and when the body receives that which is closest to the natural form it was designed to process, it takes it in much more readily.  This is maximized when nutrients are derived from nutrient-rich food.  When the absorption rates soar, the cells uptake is increased and utilization improves substantially.”

    It is a tenet of our philosophy that the human body was designed to take in and process food, utilizing those nutrients to achieve optimal health.  The farther away from food that a supplement becomes, the more foreign it is to the body.

    Are we surprised that the presumably synthetic multivitamins in these study categories failed to have an effect on advanced degenerative conditions? Not really.

    We have always recommended getting your vitamins and minerals from food and food based supplements like EGN Powerfood, Spirulina Chlorella, Krill Oil, and Himalayan Salt.

    It is Onnit’s belief, alongside top performance coaches like Mike Dolce, that the body knows what to do with earth grown nutrients and will put them to good use.

    In conclusion, while multivitamins aren’t the Onnit recommended way to get nutrients, far from the case being “closed” they still appear to be viable for mitigating many of the non-life threatening conditions that affect our day to day performance and happiness.

    It seems that more and more you have to look past the headlines in these stories to get the kernels of truth.  As a final word, I’ll leave you with a very telling abstract from the PubMed study on multivitamin supplementation for the prevention of juvenile delinquency:

    Multivitamin Conclusion

    Poor nutritional habits in children that lead to low concentrations of water-soluble vitamins in blood, impair brain function and subsequently cause violence and other serious antisocial behavior.

    Correction of nutrient intake, either through a well-balanced diet or low-dose vitamin-mineral supplementation, corrects the low concentrations of vitamins in blood, improves brain function and subsequently lowers institutional violence and antisocial behavior by almost half.

    This paper adds to the literature by enabling previous research to be generalized from older incarcerated subjects with a history of antisocial behavior to a normal population of younger children in an educational setting.

    Total Human Optimization Power Pack

    Total Human Optimization Power Pack

    $195.80 $186.01

    ONNIT CART BUTTON

    This pack is the simplest way to support your entire body. TPC is our answer to the multivitamin, offering specific nutrients and clinically tested formulas to support your total body. DigesTech ensures that the food you eat is being digested easily and delivered properly, and EGN provides the raw building blocks to cover your nutrient bases.

    Author:

    Aubrey Marcus

    Aubrey Marcus Aubrey Marcus founded Onnit in 2010 as a nutritional supplements brand based on a holistic health philosophy he calls Total Human Optimization. He has since grown Onnit into an industry leader, providing innovative peak performance supplements, foods, fitness equipment, and apparel. A 20 year native of Austin, Texas, Aubrey graduated from the University of Richmond in 2004 with a degree in philosophy and classical civilization.

    • James Smith

      I read a similar article on twitter that I tagged Joe Rogan in. I had no idea that they were trying to figure out or claim that multivitamins could help in defense of these three major diseases. It all seemed a little ridiculous to me. Anyway, the end of the article was just a “no shit” when they stated in the end a proper diet and exercise is the best way to stay healthy.

    • Pingback: Multivitamin Researchers: “Case Is Closed… Because I Said So?” | Onnit Blog – Fitness, Nutrition and Sports Science()

    • Lee

      A link to a study showing what one of your supplements can do would be nice.

    • D$

      Second what lee said. Where’s onnits study… Or are you going to ignore this like lee’s comment

    • Mike

      Whether it’s ignorance, human nature to attack things that make them feel like they are not doing all they can, or conspiracy handed down by drug manufacturers, the end result is this; people who probably don’t eat well to begin with are now less likely to support their diets with vitamins they may not be getting through proper nutrition

      • sbsaints

        You forgot about conspiracy by technocrats. Just read Carol Quigley or Zbigniew Brizinski, who still has ears in our government. These are the guys who have been in charge of all these think tanks and NGO’s that propagate false information throughout the ranks of professional and student alike. They bounce from important government regulatory job to drug company executive and back again regularly. Rather than just simple profit, which is just icing on the power cake, they truly believe in eugenics and massive population reduction.

    • Clay

      That’s funny, because I don’t use multivitamins to ‘prevent disease’ or ‘help recovery’…I use them to supplement any vitamins/nutrients that I don’t get in my normal diet…which is what they should be used for. I’ve never heard of anyone buying a Centrum because they wanted to prevent cancer. SMH.

    • http://www,reeveta.in reeveta

      I Read your Blog i.e so interesting and more knowledgeable about supplements & vitamins

    • Anonymous

      The title is a lie. Studies found no evidence for the usefulness of supplements. that does not mean they might not be useful in certain situations. And it definitely does not mean “because I said so.”

    • http://www.nestpillmart.com/ isabel marshal

      very nice posting!! i really like this blog. thanks for sharing.

    • http://www.dynamin.in/ Dynamin

      People still have confusion about usage of multivitamins and drugs. Multivitamins are something that will keep you away from health conditions, where as drugs are meant to cure diseases. Hope this will help people.

      • MarkMyWordz

        Not to be rude, but not all drugs are meant to cure diseases. In fact, I would argue that drugs are meant to help keep you alive, but if they cured everything then big pharma and doctors would be out money. Unfortunatley it doesn’t pay to completely cure people. It pays to help them with pain, put a disease into remission, or give meds that help put a bandaid over the real issue. Drugs are to keep you in a revolving door so you keep coming back to the doctors to get more medicine. I know this is a cynical way of looking at it, but its true.


    Keep-It™ Money Back Guarantee
    We’ve taken the tricks out of the Money Back Guarantee. Most companies push out mediocre products and rely on the fact that dissatisfied customers are too busy to go through the hassle of returning the product to qualify for their money back. We’re confident you’ll love your Onnit supplements, and we’re not gonna play games with you.
    Order any of our entry size supplements, and if you don’t like it, you can keep it. Notify us and we’ll give you a full refund right there on the spot. No complicated intake forms and no return necessary. We trust you, but to protect against fraud, the Keep-It™ guarantee is valid only for first time purchases of a product, and redeemable up to three months after purchase.
    Multiple bottles, foods, apparel and gear are subject to our basic, no stress money back guarantee. Fitness equipment, personal care products, knowledge purchases, and DVDs are not eligible. For more information and a full list of products that qualify, visit our Keep-It™ page. To process a refund, visit our support page.
    Military Discount
    In thanks to our military service men and women, we're extending a 15% discount on all products purchased at Onnit.com.
    Anyone shipping their order to an APO/FPO/DPO address will have a 15% discount automatically applied to their order.
    In order to validate your account, please either send an email from your .mil email address or send in a snapshot of your military ID to our customer service help desk. Blacking out rank and or post is acceptable. In either case, please include the civilian email address or whichever email address you have registered with Onnit.com somewhere in the message body so we know which account to verify. Please setup an account with Onnit.com prior to submitting your request.
    * US Military members, please choose United States as your destination country when creating your customer profile, as this will ensure your package ships via USPS and that you are not given international shipping rates.
    Subscribe & Save 15% now
    With a subscription, you'll get your favorite Onnit products whenever you want, at 15% off. All automatic, worry free, and with our same great money back guarantee.
    Cancel, pause, or adjust your order at any time, hassle free. Your credit card will only be charged when your order ships. The discount applied every time is 15% off. Since it would be weird to subscribe to a kettlebell, the subscriptions and subscription discounts are only for things you'll need often, like supplements, foods, and personal care items.

    Secure Shopping

    We implement a variety of security measures to maintain the safety of your personal information when you place an order or enter, submit, or access any information on our website. We incorporate physical, electronic, and administrative procedures to safeguard the confidentiality of your personal information, including Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) for the encryption of all financial transactions through the website. We use industry-standard, 256bit SSL encryption to protect your personal information online, and we also take several steps to protect your personal information in our facilities. For example, when you visit the website, you access servers that are kept in a secure physical environment, behind a locked cage and a hardware firewall. After a transaction, your credit card information is not stored on our servers.